Holly would initially be offended and outraged by this stupid human holiday, and probably have some stern words for Santa about exploiting her race in whatever universe he actually exists in. But after that gets cleared up, she'd like a nice new set of wings. Or maybe her old Nuetrino 2000 that she had to get rid off after the B'wa Kell rebellion back.

Terry wants to be able to celebrate the holidays with his mom and brother. Barring that, he'd like his motorcycle or the Batmobile.